Carol' Encounter More Terrifying Than Battle of Leyte

CAPTAIN Mc CLINTOCK TELLS HOW GILMORE RODE OUT THE HURRICANE

Capt. David H. McClintock, USN, says it was the courage, capabilities and loyalty of the officers and men that saved the big submarine tender Howard W. Gilmore from being badly damaged, or possibly wrecked, when it was caught by Hurricane Carol on Aug. 31, 1954 off Montauk Point, Long Island. Mem-bers of the crew, on the other hand, say it was the superb seamanship and maneuvering of Capt. McClintock that saved the huge ship and its company of nearly one thousand.


The Gilmore, now at her, berth in the navy yard, shows little sign of the battering the storm gave her, until you see inch-thick plates dented and bulkhead joints and seams pulled apart-one of the dents on the flying bridge way up, sixty feet above the normal waterline. Green water broke clear over the bridge a number of times during the worst of the storm, when the winds reached a top velocity of 110 miles an hour.


The entire crew came through the ordeal with no greater damage than severe seasickness on the part of a considerable number. But Capt. McClintock says that there was never a moments delay in response to signals at any of the stations throughout the huge ship, despite the fact that the angry ocean swept over it time and time again, and the winds and rains battered and shook and pitched it at terrifying angles.


Taking the story chronologically, the Gilmore left Key West on August 9, on a training cruise, going as far north as New Foundland. At the conclusion of the exercise, the ship headed homewards. The squadron commander was aboard and the Gilmore was heading for New London, where he and some other officers were to go ashore. At midnight, Aug. 30, Hurricane Carol was off Cape Hatteras, and moving north-ward at about 15 miles an hour. The officers agreed that they would have ample time to reach New London before the storm struck.


But Carol suddenly speeded up, until her forward movement became close to 60 miles and hour - so fast that the weather reports were unable to give ad-equate warnings. However, such news as was received led Capt. McClintock to believe that the Gilmore might skirt the hurricane by moving further out to sea. Accordingly, at 8 o'clock on the morning of the 31st, the Gilmore was southeast of Montauk Point. The barometer started to drop and within an amazingly short time the ship caught the full force of the winds, rains and seas.

The Gilmore's normal speed is 15 knots and Capt. McClintock headed the vessel into the wind, with the engines doing their best to keep from being blown shoreward, and all the steering apparatus utilized to keep the ship from getting side-wise to the winds - which when they first hit, came from the east. The Gilmore was to the east of the eye of the storm, throughout.


The hardest blows came between 8 o'clock and 11. The winds eased slightly before noon, but it was not until 5 o'clock in the afternoon that they dared turn the vessel crosswise of the seas. When the storm passed inland, the Gilmore followed it and landed its passengers safely in New London.


The Gilmore is 530 feet in length - that is nearly 200 yards - and of about 16,000 tons. There are nearly 1,000 enlisted men, and 35 officers regularly on duty, and most of them had been looking forward to arriving at New York on the morning tide, Sept. 1. As it was, they made the port of the metropolis during the afternoon and had five days of shore liberty.


While the bits of machinery and equipment in the open were swept clear of the ship by the storm, there was no damage that interfered with her return to Key West. On heading south from New York, however, there were warnings of the northward movement of Hurricane Edna. The Gilmore rounded Cape Hatteras by this time, however and moved coastward toward St. Augustine and so did not encounter any further strong winds. The tender arrived back in Key West on Sept. 10.


Captain McClintock was skipper of one of the seven submarines lost at the Battle of Leyte, Oct. 22 - 27, 1944 and barely escaped with his life. This battle, said to be the biggest naval action ever fought, resulted in the loss to the United States of a light carrier, three escort carriers, 6 destroyers, 3 destroyer escorts and one high speed transport, in addition to the seven sub-marines.

"But that Battle with Hurricane Carol, off Montauk Point," said Capt. McClintock, "was the most frightening experience I ever had." Most of the members of the crew, who were mercifully not sick, feel the same way.


Key West Newspaper-August 31, 1954